TCK: ElRelationalOperators1Test.jsp EL expression has a typo (doubl1 instead of double1)

[robertpatrick]

Challenged tests

• ee.jakarta.tck.pages.spec.core_syntax.scripting.el.URLClientIT#elRelationalOperators1Test

TCK Version
Jakarta Pages 4.0.0

Description
The ElRelationalOperators1Test.jsp has the EL expression ${float1 <= doubl1} but doubl1 is undefined. The page defines double1 instead.

Additional context
WebLogic Server correctly reports this error: jakarta.el.PropertyNotFoundException: ELResolver cannot handle a null base Object with identifier 'doubl1'

[arjantijms]

Exact line:

https://github.com/jakartaee/pages/blob/main/tck/src/main/resources/ee/jakarta/tck/pages/spec/core_syntax/scripting/el/ElRelationalOperators1Test.jsp#L53

Seems a legit error. Just odd in a way no other implementation ever stumbled upon this.

[markt-asf]

I agree this looks like a bug. However, the test should not fail since an unknown identifier should be treated as null (Pages 4.0 3.3.4) and ${ 1.5f <= null} should evaluate to false (EL 6.0 1.9.1) which is the expected result of this test.

The reason other containers have not flagged this is that they correctly treat the unknown identifier as null. It appears that WebLogic is running the TCK with an implied page attribute of errorOnELNotFound=true when the default should be false.

I am therefore accepting this as a bug (the TCK test isn't testing what it is meant to be testing) but rejecting the challenge as the buggy test should still pass in a specification compliant container.

I'll get this test fixed.

It looks like the errorOnELNotFound tests need expanding to test for the default as well as the explicit settings.