[safe-output-health] 🏥 Safe Output Health Report - 2026-05-15

[github-actions[bot]]

Executive Summary

The safe-output job pipeline is healthy. Across 57 workflow runs in the last 24 hours, zero safe-output jobs failed. The only two non-success outcomes (one activation failure, one workflow cancellation) are out of scope for this monitor — the safe-output jobs in those runs were either skipped or cancelled as collateral, not faulted.

• Period: 2026-05-14 — 2026-05-15 (last 24 hours)
• Runs Analyzed: 57
• Workflows Active: ~30
• Safe-Output Jobs Executed: 39 (38 success, 1 cancelled)
• Safe-Output Jobs Skipped (no output to emit): 18
• Safe-Output Jobs Failed: 0
• Error Clusters Identified: 0
• Verdict: ✅ Healthy

Safe Output Job Statistics

Job Type / Tool	Total Executions	Failures	Success Rate
safeoutputs.add_comment	observed (multiple)	0	100%
safeoutputs.create_discussion	observed	0	100%
safeoutputs.submit_pull_request_review	observed	0	100%
safeoutputs.noop	observed (multiple)	0	100%
Aggregated safe_outputs job	39 ran	0 failed (1 cancelled)	100%

No failures were detected for any safe-output tool invocation.

Critical Issues

None. No actionable safe-output failures were found in this audit window.

Out-of-Scope Findings (not safe-output failures)

These were the only non-success outcomes observed; both are excluded from this monitor's scope per the runbook (agent/activation failures are tracked separately).

1. Linter Miner — activation failure

• Run: §25898144570
• Workflow: Linter Miner (workflow_dispatch)
• Failed Job: activation (exit code 1)
• Safe-output Job Status: skipped (never ran)
• Why not a safe-output issue: The safe-output job was correctly skipped because activation never produced any output. The pipeline behaved as designed when an upstream job fails.

2. Smoke CI — workflow cancellation

• Run: §25900857318
• Workflow: Smoke CI (push)
• Conclusion: cancelled
• Safe-output Job Status: cancelled (26s into execution; error_count=0 in metrics)
• Agent Outcome: Agent reached a clean safeoutputs.noop decision before cancellation ("smoke-ci: push event - no PR context, no action needed")
• Why not a safe-output issue: The safe-output job was cancelled as collateral when the overall workflow run was cancelled. No internal fault, no API error, no data corruption.

Root Cause Analysis

• API-Related Issues: None observed.
• Data Validation / Parsing Issues: None observed.
• Permission Issues: None observed.
• Network / Timeout Issues: None observed.
• Logic Errors in safe-output scripts: None observed.

All observed safeoutputs.* tool invocations completed with non-error status and the downstream safe_outputs jobs successfully posted comments/discussions/reviews to GitHub.

Recommendations

No immediate actions required. The system is operating within expected parameters.

Maintenance Suggestions (low priority)

1. Track cancelled vs. failed safe_outputs job conclusions distinctly in reporting

   • Why: The aggregated error_count field in the run summary surfaced 2 for the cancelled Smoke CI run, even though no safe-output fault occurred. Future audits should continue distinguishing genuine failures from cancellation collateral to avoid noise.
   • Affected: Safe Output Health Monitor analysis logic (this workflow).

2. Consider sampling successful safe-output runs for latency/duration baselines

   • Why: With zero failures, the next signal worth tracking is performance drift (e.g., safe-output job duration creep). Today's sample showed durations 13–27s for safe_outputs jobs, well within normal.
   • Affected: This monitor's future scope.

Work Item Plans

No work items required for this audit window — system is healthy.

Historical Context

This is the first audit recorded in cache memory (/tmp/gh-aw/cache-memory/safe-output-health/). Establishing the baseline:

• Baseline success rate: 100% (0 failures across 57 runs)
• Most-invoked safe-output tools: noop, add_comment, create_discussion, submit_pull_request_review
• Engine mix in window: 9 claude runs, 34 copilot runs, ~14 other

Future audits will use this as the comparison anchor for trend analysis.

Metrics and KPIs

• Overall Safe Output Success Rate: 100%
• Most Reliable Job Type: All tied at 100%
• Most Problematic Job Type: None
• Average Wall-Clock for safe_outputs job: ~13–27s (sampled)

Next Steps

• Cache memory updated with 2026-05-15 baseline
• Pattern database initialized (empty — no patterns yet)
• Re-audit in next scheduled run; compare against this baseline
• If failures appear in a future window, cluster and root-cause them here

---

References:

• Audit run: §25902007097
• Out-of-scope activation failure: §25898144570
• Out-of-scope cancellation: §25900857318

Generated by 🔒 Safe Output Health Monitor · ● 11.9M · ◷

• expires on May 16, 2026, 5:38 AM UTC

[github-actions[bot]]

This discussion has been marked as outdated by Safe Output Health Monitor.

A newer discussion is available at Discussion #32552.